The shore seen from above, palms and white sand
About the reserve

A shore bought back one lot at a time, and never sold on.

Opened in 2016 at twenty-four keys. Still twenty-four, still nothing taller than the palms.

The reserve from the air: the reef pool, villas and the shoreline
The short version

Built slowly, and then stopped.

Isabel Lim grew up on this shore. When the family lots were sold off in the nineties she spent twelve years buying them back, one neighbour at a time, with no plan beyond keeping the reef in front of them quiet.

The plan came later and had a hard ceiling: eight villas, sixteen rooms, one restaurant, one pool, and a beach with more loungers than guests. The last villa opened in 2019 and the ceiling stayed.

The villas and rooms
The people

Four people you will probably meet.

Isabel Amara Roberts

Founder and owner

Grew up on this shore and bought the neighbouring lots back one at a time over twelve years. Set the rule: eight villas, sixteen rooms, and not one more.

Rafael Quintana

General manager

Twenty years in resorts across the Caribbean and the Gulf. Runs the house from the beach hut, not the office.

Tomas Abella

Chef, Windward

Buys off the Key Largo docks at 5:00 AM and writes the menu afterwards.

Dr. Liza Fernandez

Reef program

Marine biologist. Surveys the patch reefs monthly with the sanctuary team and leads the guided swims.

Timeline

From six lots to a coral nursery.

Every addition was paid for by the last one. No investors, no chain.

2004
Isabel Roberts buys back the first of six lots on the family shore at mile marker 97.
2011
The last lot closes. 720 feet of shore, one owner, no plan for a hotel yet.
2014
First survey with the sanctuary team. Our boats go on the mooring buoys and stop anchoring anywhere near coral.
2016
Amara Reserve opens with four villas and the main house. Nothing taller than the palms.
2019
Four more villas and the spa in the grove complete the twenty-four keys.
2023
A 60 kW solar array, and nursery trees on the patch reef worked with the local restoration crews.
Stewardship

Rainwater, reef rules and sun on every roof.

Rainwater first

Six 8,000 gallon tanks run the gardens, pool top-ups and laundry through the wet months, May to October.

Reef rules

No touching coral, reef-safe sunscreen only, which the state stopped the Keys from making law, so here it is a house rule, and everyone stays inside the marked lanes.

Sun on every roof

Solar water heating in every key and a 60 kW array covering about half of daytime power.

Local by default

Fish off the Key Largo docks, vegetables from the grove garden and from Homestead, and 52 of 60 staff live between Key Largo and Tavernier.

Less to throw away

Glass bottles in every villa, refill stations in the house, kitchen scraps to the compost.

The coral nursery

Guests can join the reef team on the first Sunday of the month to hang fragments on the nursery trees.

Reef rules, in short

Five things every guest agrees to on arrival.

  1. No touching or standing on coral.
  2. Reef-safe sunscreen only. Florida stopped the Keys making that law, so here it is a house rule, and a bottle is in your villa.
  3. No fish feeding, and no coral, conch or sea fans taken home. Out here that is a federal offence, not a house rule.
  4. Swim, snorkel and paddle inside the marked lanes.
  5. Shore lights off after 9:00 PM in turtle season, which here is May to October.

Come see the reef for yourself.

Villas with private pools, rooms in the main house, one rate that includes breakfast.